China’s rise defies the monolithic authoritarian view; its actions reflect politics, economics, history, regional priorities, warning against flawed policy.
After 1991, the central error of U.S. economic statecraft was not adherence to any single doctrine—market fundamentalism, free-trade universalism, or neoliberal reform—but the deeper meta-error of treating those doctrines as natural laws rather than contingent tools. The absence of a peer rival was mistaken for the end of competition; a fleeting unipolar moment was misread … Read more
After the Cold War, the United States elevated a cluster of post-1991 doctrines—market fundamentalism, free-trade universalism, end-of-history liberalism, anti-industrial and asset-light biases, financialization as progress, limited-government absolutism, global capital mobility, consumer-welfare reductionism, and the assumption of peace through trade—into something approaching natural law. The meta-error was not any single ideology, but the belief that these … Read more
In Permanent Distortion: How the Financial Markets Abandoned the Real Economy Forever (2022), Nomi Prins advances a structural rather than a purely ideological explanation for the West’s retreat from the real economy. She does not argue that this shift was driven primarily by Fukuyama’s “End of History” thesis or by the confidence of a Pax … Read more
In Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade (2007) and Kicking Away the Ladder (2002), Ha-Joon Chang challenges the conventional narrative that wealth is built through strict adherence to free-market principles. He argues that historically, rich countries became prosperous not by following liberal economic rules but by actively intervening in their economies—through tariffs, protectionism, subsidies, … Read more
In 2016, the World Economic Forum reported that China produced approximately 4.7 million STEM graduates annually, compared with 2.6 million in India and about 568,000 in the United States. This scale of STEM output is not incidental; it underpins China’s strength in engineering-intensive sectors and helps explain outcomes such as its dominance in industrial robotics, … Read more
A persistent narrative in Western media attributes China’s manufacturing dominance to suppressed labor rights and artificially low wages, portraying its success as the product of a “sweatshop” model. Yet this explanation collapses under comparative scrutiny. India, where millions of young workers earn less than their Chinese counterparts, has failed to develop a comparable manufacturing base; … Read more
Some critics portray China’s full industrial chain as “anti-specialization,” a violation of comparative advantage, or even a contradiction of freedom and prosperity. Such views rest on a narrow understanding of specialization. In reality, a full industrial chain does not negate specialization; it represents its most advanced form, in which highly differentiated, interdependent, and efficient segments … Read more
China’s commitment to domestic substitution extends beyond technological or economic considerations; it is a strategic choice shaped by historical lessons, contemporary threats, systemic security, and the imperatives of a civilization with 1.4 billion people. This focus on self-reliance is fundamentally about the right to survival and development, a rational response to technological bottlenecks and external … Read more
Former Singaporean Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew (LKY) long argued that China would struggle to reach the global frontier of creativity because its political system constrained dissent, independent thinking, and intellectual freedom; in his view, China would excel at absorbing and refining foreign technologies but not at pioneering them. Yet today, China has produced notable … Read more
China pursued an industrial strategy that emphasized protecting national sovereignty, learning progressively, and implementing changes gradually, in stark contrast to countries that opted for rapid liberalization and consequently lost influence over their industrial development. Sovereignty and Control Over Foreign Capital China has consistently prioritized maintaining national sovereignty in its economic development, in contrast to countries … Read more