Industrial Policy

China’s state sets goals, takes risks, and builds scale, while firms compete and innovate—an integrated system the market-driven U.S. struggles to match.

China’s Production Discipline vs. U.S. Pressure-Group Capture

by

Shenzhen’s rise as a shopping and consumer paradise reflects the effects of freer markets, open competition, and rapid supply expansion. By contrast, persistently high prices in Hong Kong—and similarly in the United States—stem from institutional constraints, including restrictive land-use policies, labor barriers, professional monopolies, and protectionist regulations. These mechanisms limit entry and suppress competition, driving … Read more

Finance First: How the West Traded Production for Power

by

In Permanent Distortion: How the Financial Markets Abandoned the Real Economy Forever (2022), Nomi Prins advances a structural rather than a purely ideological explanation for the West’s retreat from the real economy. She does not argue that this shift was driven primarily by Fukuyama’s “End of History” thesis or by the confidence of a Pax … Read more

China vs. U.S.: How Infrastructure Shapes Autonomous Driving

by

In Finance and the Real Economy: China and the West Since the Asian Financial Crisis (2020), Peter Nolan argues that China’s post-2008 development trajectory was shaped by a distinctive framework of state-led finance, infrastructure-led growth, and long-term industrial strategy. In response to the global financial crisis, China launched a coordinated wave of investment in “new … Read more

Finance, Infrastructure, and AI: The China–West Divergence

by

Since the Asian Financial Crisis, China and Western economies have followed sharply diverging paths in the relationship between finance and the real economy. As Peter Nolan argues in Finance and the Real Economy: China and the West Since the Asian Financial Crisis (2020), China has consistently deployed finance to support infrastructure, production, employment, and productivity, … Read more

U.S. Lacks Real-World AI Scenarios, Digital Finance Shows Why

by

The United States currently leads in frontier AI research and innovation, yet it faces persistent challenges in system-level deployment and large-scale integration. These constraints stem not from technological limitations but from structural factors, including decades of manufacturing hollowing, fragmented governance, and weak coordination across public and private actors. As a result, the U.S. often lacks … Read more

China’s Climb: Navigating a Global Ladder Kicked Away

by

In Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade (2007) and Kicking Away the Ladder (2002), Ha-Joon Chang challenges the conventional narrative that wealth is built through strict adherence to free-market principles. He argues that historically, rich countries became prosperous not by following liberal economic rules but by actively intervening in their economies—through tariffs, protectionism, subsidies, … Read more

China’s Development Path: Historical Pattern, Not Aberration

by

Debates over whether China’s development path is historically aberrant often overlook a well-documented pattern of late industrialization. As Ha-Joon Chang argues in Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism (2007), China’s strategies—state intervention, selective protectionism, subsidies, and the copying or weak protection of foreign technologies—closely mirror those once employed … Read more

Why China Scales STEM Graduates While the U.S. System Cannot

by

In 2016, the World Economic Forum reported that China produced approximately 4.7 million STEM graduates annually, far exceeding India’s 2.6 million and the United States’ 568,000. This vast output of technical talent translates directly into industrial capability: by 2024, China had become the world’s largest market for industrial robotics, accounting for 54 percent of global … Read more

How China’s Gaokao-Centered System Produces STEM Scale

by

In 2016, the World Economic Forum reported that China produced approximately 4.7 million STEM graduates annually, compared with 2.6 million in India and about 568,000 in the United States. This scale of STEM output is not incidental; it underpins China’s strength in engineering-intensive sectors and helps explain outcomes such as its dominance in industrial robotics, … Read more

China’s Rise Mirrors Rich Nations’ Past—Ladder Kicked Away

by

In Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism (2007), Ha-Joon Chang argues that the economic histories of today’s advanced nations follow a recurring and often obscured pattern. Countries such as Germany and Japan began with industries widely stigmatized for low quality, then relied on protectionist policies, state support, and … Read more